Everyone from
Jay-Z to
President Obama has weighed in on Kanye West's
controversial interruption of Taylor Swift's acceptance speech at last weekend's MTV Video Music Awards. But we're sure that some of you, our thoughtful and highly intelligent readers, won't be satisfied until you get the nuts-and-bolts philosophical-psychological perspective on the incident. Right? Right?
Wait no longer, friends. Over on the Psychology Today blog The Natural Unconscious, John Bargh, who teaches psychology and cognitive science at Yale, dissects Kanye's explanation for the break-in, which, when he was on Jay Leno, he attributed not to his own actions but to the pain caused by his mother's death. (Which happened in 2007, but let that go for the moment.) The problem, as Bargh sees it, starts with the question of free will and causality, and that's where our own Dan Wegner's The Illusion of Conscious Will comes in. Dan argued in that book that we do not have access to our own information about our causal influence on the world. That is, as Bargh puts it, "we can't use just our feelings of having caused our behavior as some kind of prima facie evidence that we did indeed cause it."
Thus, Bargh continues:
[West] did not take personal responsibility for what he had done, but
instead apologized that "his own pain caused someone else's pain". He
was saying, in other words, that he did not intend his behavior, he did
not freely choose it, but instead it was caused by the understandable pain he still felt over the loss of his mother.
Now, Mr West has been roundly criticized in the media for not taking
personal responsibility for his own actions and trying to focus the
public's attention on his own suffering and not the embarrassment
and humiliation he caused Ms Swift. But we should realize that his
sudden, and quite convenient abandonment of his own presumed belief in
free will, is something we all tend to do, although usually not on
the Jay Leno show in front of 30 million viewers.
Once again, scholarship rides to the rescue of pop culture. Read the whole thing here.